Jay County's Most Wanted
The suspects listed below have active warrants out of Jay County.  Do not attempt to apprehend them yourselves. Contact the Jay County Sheriff's Office at 260-726-8188 and advise them of the time and location you last saw the suspect.  You may also leave a message on the "Report a Crime" link on this website.  If you believe you have an active warrant, you may also leave a message through the "Report a Crime" link and someone will contact you as soon as possible.
All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law!
Fraley, Eric D
Probation Violation
Class C Felony
Jay Circuit CourtHenderson, Martin F
Non Support of Dependant
Class C Felony
Jay Circuit CourtKnight, Steven R
Nonsupport of a Dependant Child
Class C Felony
Jay Circuit CourtQuezada, Roman Martinez
Failure to Appear
Class C Felony
Jay Circuit CourtShepler, Matthew S
Probation Violation 
Class B Felony 
Jay Circuit CourtStewart, Jacob T
Dealing in Schedule II Controlled Substance
Class B Felony
Jay Circuit Court
Jay County Circuit Court
Jay Superior Court
Babbitt, George M
Conversion
Class A Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtBeard, James D
3 Counts Dealing Marijuana
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtBell, Steven N
Operating Vehicle After Forfeit License
Class C Felony 
Jay Superior CourtBess, William J
Driving While Suspended
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtBishop, Sherman R
Batter Resulting in Bodily Injury
Class D Felony 
Jay Superior CourtBruckner, Richard J
Conversion
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtBuckson, Anthony D
Operating While Intoxicated
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtBurton, James C
Operating While Intoxicated
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtCaster, Michael D
Operating While Intoxicated
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtContreras-Guzman, Mathias
Theft
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtCousins, William J III
Operating While Intoxicated
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtCrist, Nicole R
Probation Violation
Class A Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtCruz, Martin L
Operating While Intoxicated
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtDrummond, Harold G Jr
Operating While Intoxicated
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtDuenez-Munoz Miguel D
Operating While Intoxicated
Resisting
Class A Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtGips, Tommie J
Operating While Intoxicated
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior Court
Gonzalez, Jorge A
Operating While Intoxicated
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtGrimes, David 
Poss of Marijuana  
Operating While Intoxicated
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtHale, Shannon A
Probation Violation
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtHerl, Terry L JR
Theft
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtHughes, Joshua D
Possession Of Marijuana
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtHuntley, Jeremy A
2 Counts Theft
Class D Felony
Jay Superior Court
Lajti, Garrett A
Criminal Mischief
Class B Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtMesita. Carina Galvan
Theft
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtPenrod, Kirk A
Nonsupport of a Dependant
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtPerez-Torres, Felipe De Jesus
Resisting Law Enforcement
Class D Felony 
Jay Superior CourtReedy, Joshua J
Automobile Theft
Class D Felony 
Jay Superior CourtRios, Guillermo A
Operating While Intoxicated
Class A Misdemeanor
Operating While Intoxicated 
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtRivas, Herninino
Possession Of Marijuana
Class C Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtRyf, Brandon E
Possession of Marijuana
Class D Felony 
Jay Superior CourtSells, Chad A
Theft
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtSells, Ezra
Theft
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtSmith, Ninfa
Interference with Custody
Class D Felony
Jay Superior CourtStahley, Phillip M
Probation Violation
Class C Felony
Jay Superior CourtThomas, Katrina L
Driving While Suspended
Class A Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtTrusty, MichaelL L
Operating While Intoxicated Endangering
Possession Of Marijuana
Class A MIisdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtVail, Jorge A
Driving While Suspended
Class A Misdemeanor
Jay Superior CourtYates, Richard A III
Battery Resulting in Bodily Injury
Class A Misdemeanor
Jay Superior Court
Click on the Picture to enlarge and see charges.